November 25, 2003


Boy, do I feel safer...not.

Posse Comitatus. Has nothing to do with those old westerns we like to watch; and almost everything to do with some of them. Confused? Like most Americans, I prefer my Law Enforcement to be done by ummmm, Professional or at least Trained Police Officers. Not soldiers. Posse Comitatus was the law that forbade Federal Troops from acting as police in local venues. It was a good law, until the republicans got ahold of it in the "War on Drugs"...that little disaster that preceeded the War on Terra™.

Now there's a whole new command structure set up within the military to begin working against Posse Comitatus with the blessings of the Congresscritters and the 1600 Crew. Our liberties, pissed on again.

Preoccupied with the war in Iraq and still traumatized by Sept. 11, 2001, the American public has paid little attention to some of what is being done inside the United States in the name of anti-terrorism. Under the banner of "homeland security," the military and intelligence communities are implementing far-reaching changes that blur the lines between terrorism and other kinds of crises and will break down long-established barriers to military action and surveillance within the U.S.
...
The U.S. military operates under the 1878 Posse Comitatus Act, which prohibits the direct use of federal troops "to execute the laws" of the United States. The courts have interpreted this to mean that the military is prohibited from any active role in direct civilian law enforcement, such as search, seizure or arrest of civilians.
...
Eberhart says his Northern Command operates scrupulously within the bounds of the law. "We believe the [Posse Comitatus] Act, as amended, provides the authority we need to do our job, and no modification is needed at this time," he told the House Armed Services Committee in March.

Of course, what he knows is that amendments approved by Congress in 1996 for that earlier civilian war, the war on drugs, have already expanded the military's domestic powers so that Washington can act unilaterally in dispatching the military without waiting for a state's request for help. Long before 9/11, Congress authorized the military to assist local law enforcement officials in domestic "drug interdiction" and during terrorist incidents involving weapons of mass destruction. Furthermore, the president, after proclaiming a state of emergency, can authorize additional actions.

Indeed, the military is presently operating under just such an emergency declaration. Eberhart's command has defined three levels of operations, each of which triggers a larger set of authorized activities. The levels are "extraordinary," "emergency" and "temporary."

Well, isn't that frightening. Just what we need, soldiers at check points...say the on and off-ramps of Interstates to make sure that you are who you say you are. Welcome to (a)Nazi Germany or choice (b) the USSR. How fun. Thanks, you Miserable Failure, thanks a lot.

posted by Jo Fish on 11.25.03 at 11:47 PM





Comments:

I don't understand the problem. Why can't troops operate in the police role?

It's working perfectly in Iraq, isn't it?

Isn't it?

Hello?

posted by: Lurch on 11.26.03 at 08:21 AM [permalink]



Thanks for blogging this. I was asking similar questions a few months ago but was reassured that National Guard isn't covered by posse comitatus, so I was overreacting.
I guess not.

posted by: Lis on 11.26.03 at 10:37 AM [permalink]



When I was in basic language school at Indiana University the University president asked the AF detachment commander to assist the campus police with a 'panty raid' being talked up at the school.

The commander had to explain to IU exactly how illegal that would be.

The other problem with this crack in the wall is that NSA only did military targets because it is part of the Department of Defense. Civilian stuff would be picked up, but it was trashed as soon as it was identified as non-military.

The same rules were in effect for all the DoD intelligence units. Now they are going to want to use the DoD for other things under the cover of terrorism. This is a very bad idea.

As for the Guard, they are state unless specifically called up to Federal service. The Guard is an absolute necessity for those of us in the 'hurricane zone'.

posted by: Bryan on 11.26.03 at 06:32 PM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?



















usdemvet -at- hotmail.com
or
usndemvet -at- usdemvet.com (coming soon)






All the original material © 2002-2003 Jo Fish
steal what you want, all I ask is an attribution of some sort
Thanks