August 26, 2004


Don and the Giant Torture Machine

Dahlia Lithwick:

This week's report by the James Schlesinger panel offers the closest thing we'll get to a smoking gun. Connect the dots and it's all there: the sadism at Abu Ghraib stemmed from "confusion." Confusion sounds accidental - like maybe it just blew in off the Atlantic - but the report is clear that this confusion resulted from systemic failures at the highest levels. The report faults ambiguous interrogation mandates, an inadequate postwar plan, poor training and a lack of oversight. It notes that much of this confusion stemmed from the Bush administration's posture that the Geneva Conventions applied only where the president saw fit, and that the definition of "interrogation" was up for grabs at Guantánamo Bay, thus possibly at Abu Ghraib.

Or you can put your ear right up to the horse's mouth, where - even before the Schlesinger report - Mr. Rumsfeld owned the blame. "These events occurred on my watch. As secretary of defense, I am accountable for them and I take full responsibility," he told the Senate Armed Services Committee last May. But we live in an era when such words are intended to signify simultaneous culpability and absolution.

Which sounds about right, but I think she overstates the 1600 Crew's idea of what accountability is ... as far as they're concerned, it's for the other guy.

Especially Decorated Vietnam Veterans running for President. For instance.

And then there's this thought:

The ranking terrorists we do catch? They disappear into yet more law-free zones for further interrogation. The same intelligence-at-any-price culture that led us to Abu Ghraib keeps the real terrorists from ever being held to account.
Sure, or is it Reinhard Gehlen time again, anyone? We're past masters at that kind of shit, especially in some parts of the intelligence community.

posted by Jo Fish on 08.26.04 at 12:13 AM





Comments:

"Or you can put your ear right up to the horse's mouth ...." What about the other half of the horse in the White House?

posted by: Shag from Brookline on 08.26.04 at 06:45 AM [permalink]



Off topic, but ...

Cleveland Scene, an alternative paper in Cleveland, has a nice rundown of GOP wrongdoing here in the "battleground state of Ohio."

http://www.clevescene.com/issues/2004-08-25/feature.html

posted by: Tony Goins on 08.26.04 at 12:05 PM [permalink]



Ashcroft is part of this. AG has some say in detainees and Americans stationed abroad in any capacity. Patriot act.


Alien TORT reform. TORTure reform?

posted by: Mr.Murder on 08.31.04 at 11:36 PM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?



















usdemvet -at- hotmail.com
or
usndemvet -at- usdemvet.com (coming soon)






All the original material © 2002-2003 Jo Fish
steal what you want, all I ask is an attribution of some sort
Thanks