July 20, 2005


Training new soldiers - Iraqi Style

One of the most pernicious, and yet most believed lies that falls out of Fearless Leader's mouth has been that the Iraqi Army is getting ready to "take over" with just a skosh more training. Take over what, I'm not sure. Juan Cole has an excellent essay up written by a former Australian Army officer pointing out what it takes to train a soldier. His point: the training of the Iraqi's is failing and will continue to do so.

I am an Australian. A former Australian army officer, indeed. And I say that Australia could not send more than two battalions (it has only six, most understrength) to Iraq or anywhere else for more than a year without suffering terminal damage to its structure. And two battalions would not make the slightest contribution to the internal security of the country.

Further, I was a trainer of soldiers at one time. (For two years after I returned from Vietnam, in fact.) And I state without fear of contradiction by any professional that the Iraqi army will not be in any shape to operate effectively for many, many years, given the present training program, such as it is.

There was no pre-war planning for establishment of a new Iraqi army, and Rumsfeld has been fooled by pathetic yes-men generals to believe that an Iraqi army can be trained from scratch to be a useful force in a couple of years. This is nonsense. (Just as it is nonsense to say that the Afghan National Army is anywhere near being effective.) Let me tell you what it takes to train a soldier who comes off the streets and into barracks:

We have to presuppose clean barrack-room accommodation, including decent beds, lavatories, mess halls and showers; arrangements for pay that result in families receiving cash on time; and a welfare system that caters for both recruits and their families. There must be padres for all religious denominations. (Please stop laughing.)
...
All these instructors work their asses off for 12 weeks, for at least 12 hours a day, to produce a basic soldier. And let me emphasize that what they produce is the absolute BASIC soldier -- no more. The product is not a fighting man. He is incapable of employing his individual skills immediately in a team -- a fighting platoon - because there is much more to learn before joining his battalion.

The soldier (we are talking infantry, here ; forget the much longer training for technical arms and the administrative services) then has to go off to specialist training to fit him for his unit. This takes another two months or so. Then his theoretical knowledge is put into practice in the battalion, in which he is a member of a platoon. --- But he will only function reasonably if he joins a trained platoon of skilled soldiers who are themselves a team and who trust their commander and non-commissioned leaders.

It goes on. Worth a read. Those who have been there and done that and got the T-shirt will identify with it all. One of Rumsfelds mistakes was assuming that a training apparatus could be set up and functioning at his whim. Rummy being one of the few Neocons who actually wore a uniform (sigh, he was a Naval Aviator too) had a training experience that I can speak too with great familiarity; the Naval Air Training Command is structured to be unforgiving and brutal in it's assessment of a young trainees skills on every single flight. It's set up that way and has been fine-tuned by decades of experience. What Rumsfeld experienced was even in the 1950s a process that took a young man with nothing other than the physical aptitude a desire to succeed and made him into a Naval Aviator.

There is no system in place any longer for that to happen in Iraq; the 1600 Crew disbanded it after the invasion, because they were out looking for candy and flowers in the streets along with those pesky still-unfound WMDs. Losers.

posted by Jo Fish on 07.20.05 at 06:05 PM





Comments:

Aw, geez, deja vu again. Vietnamization / Iraqization.

posted by: Mike on 07.21.05 at 02:50 PM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?



















usdemvet -at- hotmail.com
or
usndemvet -at- usdemvet.com (coming soon)






All the original material © 2002-2003 Jo Fish
steal what you want, all I ask is an attribution of some sort
Thanks