August 30, 2005


Half-Right

Well this'll get the christo-fascisti up in arms no doubt. The Air Force has decided that it's not really such a good idea to piss in the spiritual wheeties of the non-christian amongst them. Sort of.

The Air Force issued new religion guidelines to its commanders yesterday that caution against promoting any particular faith - or even "the idea of religion over nonreligion" - in official communications or functions like meetings, sports events and ceremonies.

The guidelines discourage public prayers at official Air Force events or meetings other than worship services, one of the most contentious issues for many commanders. But they allow for "a brief nonsectarian prayer" at special ceremonies like those honoring promotions, or in "extraordinary circumstances" like "mass casualties, preparation for imminent combat and natural disasters."
...
The guidelines apply not just to the academy, but also to the entire Air Force. They will be made final later this year after Air Force generals meet and consider recommendations from their commanders.
...
Rabbi Resnicoff said some Air Force members he had spoken with "mistakenly assumed" that because the military encouraged "spiritual strength as a pillar of leadership," they were given license to promote strong belief in Christianity within it.

Any educated Air Force officer who offered that up as an excuse for their actions is either lying through their teeth or is a dolt of incredible proportions. I go with choice one, myself. One of the guys who pushed this with the Air Force, an academy grad has it right though...
But one outspoken critic, Mikey Weinstein, an academy graduate from Albuquerque, said the guidelines meant nothing because the Air Force had refused to discipline officers who overstepped the boundaries.

"All this does is increase the level of confusion," Mr. Weinstein said.

He's right. Without singling out what's "bad behavior" and what isn't, the Air Force is just setting themselves up to be in this same position down the road. Their guidlines are nothing more than closing their eyes and clicking their heels together while singing kumbaya. Wishing is not going to make this go away, it's already become too embedded in their culture. Unfortunately, they are going to have to walk the walk, or nothing will change.

And we'll all be reading about this again. You'd think in light of all the scandals that have flowed forth from the AF Academy they'd break the code sooner or later on how to deal with miscreants. Absent another epic scandal soon, I guess not.

posted by Jo Fish on 08.30.05 at 10:06 AM





Comments:

A buddy of mine who is a senior prof at the Naval Academy now put the whole service academy ethics conundrum in a nutshell.

You take a bunch of kids from average homes, slap a bunch of rules on them that make no sense whatsoever, and spend four years teaching them how to break the rules without getting caught.

Jeff

posted by: Jeff Huber on 08.30.05 at 12:52 PM [permalink]



Any educated Air Force officer who offered that up as an excuse for their actions is either lying through their teeth or is a dolt of incredible proportions. I go with choice one, myself.

Jo, pardon me while I swoon. You're probably the first Naval Aviator of my acquaintance who wouldn't eagerly jump at the chance to call an Air Force puke a dolt.

;-)

Then again, "lying through his teeth" and "a dolt of incredible proportions" isn't a mutually exclusive choice. *grin*

posted by: Len Cleavelin on 08.30.05 at 02:10 PM [permalink]



It really is bad. I've read many APR/EPRs and it seems that religous activity is always looked at as a strength in community involvement. But for some reason I never did see any of that involvement outside of the religous community itself. Trust me, you'll see the nonreligous just as active outside in the community. I personally would like to see religous involvement axed from any performance report. Why? Because if the situation is as bad as it seems, the religous are getting an improper leg up by reviewers who see religion as good, nonreligion as bad.

posted by: Ray Robinson on 08.30.05 at 08:56 PM [permalink]



Coincidence?

At the same time Air Force Academy cadets were being religiously, ideologically raped by a bunch of "macho-men" religious fanatics, several dozen female cadets were physically raped by a bunch of "macho-men" rapists.

Maybe, it has to do with the view of conservative, religious types that male equals dominant while female equals subservient?

Nah, just a coincidence.

posted by: The Oracle on 08.30.05 at 10:50 PM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?



















usdemvet -at- hotmail.com
or
usndemvet -at- usdemvet.com (coming soon)






All the original material © 2002-2003 Jo Fish
steal what you want, all I ask is an attribution of some sort
Thanks